The rise and fall of Marissa Mayer, the once beloved CEO of Yahoo

Marissa Mayer
Marissa Mayer, CEO of Yahoo. AP Photo/Lionel Cironneau

Hopes were high when Marissa Mayer was hired as Yahoo CEO in 2012. People thought she would turn around the perennially dysfunctional internet giant.

Advertisement

But three years in and Mayer's time at Yahoo has been marred by slowing growth and internal dissent, leading to plummeting employee morale.

Now, some Yahoo investors are demanding a change in management, including a replacement for Mayer.

We went through a bunch of recent news stories and Nicholas Carlson's book — "Marissa Mayer and the Fight to Save Yahoo!" — to put together the story of Mayer's epic rise to become one of the biggest Silicon Valley power players and her sudden fall.

Advertisement

Mayer was born in 1975 in a small Wisconsin town called Wausau. Her father was an engineer and her mother was an art teacher.

Wausau Wisconsin
Google Maps

She developed an early talent for math and science, and teachers loved her. Although she was a good presenter, her friends didn't take her as particularly extroverted. In fact, Mayer once described the child version of herself as "painfully shy."

Marissa Mayer
Wausau West High School Yearbook
Advertisement

Mayer applied to 10 schools and got accepted to all of them, including Harvard, Yale, and Stanford. She ended up going to Stanford, where she first took premed courses, in hopes of becoming a doctor.

marissa mayer
Marissa Mayer/Google+

But her life perspective changed when she took an introductory computer-science class called CS105. It led her to major in symbolic systems, a famous major whose alumni include LinkedIn's Reid Hoffman, Apple's Scott Forstall, and Instagram's Mike Krieger.

stanford university
PROKazuhisa OTSUBO/flickr
Advertisement

People say she didn't have a very social life in college. By the time she graduated, Mayer already had 12 job offers lined up. The last offer came from Google, a small startup at the time.

google
Google co-founders Sergey Brin, left, and Larry Page at company headquarters in Mountain View, Calif. AP/Ben Margot

Mayer was planning to take a job at management-consulting firm McKinsey at the time. Plus, when she did her own analysis, Google only had a 2% chance of surviving. But she was fascinated by the people and thought she'd learn more there. She took the Google offer — and worked there for the next 13 years.

Google headquarters
Robert Galbraith/Reuters
Advertisement

Mayer loved it at Google. During her first two years, she would work 100-hour weeks regularly. She also continued to teach at Stanford for the first few years at Google.

Google Headquarters Sign
tshein via Flickr

Mayer quickly rose through the ranks. She started out as a part-time member of the user interface team, but soon became a product manager. By 2003, she was in charge of Google's consumer products, including its core search.

marissa mayer at google
Marissa Mayer at Google Robert Galbraith/Reuters
Advertisement

Mayer also briefly dated Google cofounder Larry Page. The relationship was very discreet, and they didn't show any affection in the office. One person described the relationship as, "Two quiet people dating each other quietly."

Larry Page
Seth Wenig/AP

Mayer was named VP of search products and user experience in 2005. By then, she was already setting the agenda for the product meetings that involved Larry Page. She was part of a small group of star executives called the "secret cabal," according to Steven Levy, who wrote a book on Google.

marissa mayer obama
Kevin Lamarque / REUTERS
Advertisement

She was great with the press, and the media loved her back, too. There were rumors of Google running a separate PR team just for Mayer. That wasn't true, but Google did have a group of PR people devoted to promoting her career.

vogue marissa mayer
Twitter/Reformed Broker

Mayer boosted her public presence by spending her riches conspicuously. She bought the $5 million penthouse suite at the Four Seasons in San Francisco, and another home closer to Google's Mountain View campus. She's worn dresses by designer Oscar de la Renta.

Marissa Mayer
AP
Advertisement

But her obsessive attention to detail and data-driven management style created some enemies at Google. A famous designer named Doug Bowman quit over it, saying, "I've grown tired of debating such minuscule design decisions. There are more exciting design problems in this world to tackle."

marissa mayer google
Hubpages

Frustration continued to grow internally. One of the most powerful Googlers who didn't get along with Mayer was Amit Singhal, the man behind the algorithms that power the search engine. He went directly to Larry Page and asked him to remove Mayer from the search team.

Amit Singhal
Flickr / Niall Kennedy
Advertisement

Mayer was eventually moved to the team that managed Google Maps and local products. She was still one of the top executives, but some people took it as a "demotion" because she was no longer in charge of Google's most important product: its search engine.

Marissa Mayer
Ethan Miller/Getty Images

By 2011, Mayer's great run at Google was coming to an end. But another great opportunity came: Yahoo's board wanted her to be its new CEO. Other people discussed were Nikesh Arora, then the chief business officer at Google, and Eddy Cue, Apple's senior vice president of internet software and services.

Yahoo! logo
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Advertisement

Some insiders had reservations about hiring her because Mayer didn't have a lot of experience managing the finances of a business. She was more of a product person than an operational CEO. Regardless, the board unanimously voted her in as Yahoo's next CEO.

Marissa Mayer Yahoo
REUTERS/Denis Balibouse

She started at Yahoo in July 2012. Expectations were so high that people put up posters of Mayer designed in the style of US President Barack Obama's famous "Hope" posters.

mayer hope
Yahoo
Advertisement

Mayer quickly overhauled Yahoo's existing management, and brought in her own people. During her first year, Yahoo's stock went from $15.74 per share to hovering around $28 in August 2013.

marissa mayer filo
Flickr/Marissa Mayer

But some of that success was due to Yahoo's partial ownership in Alibaba. Until Alibaba went public in 2014, Mayer was in a safe spot because Yahoo stock was one of the only few ways to invest in the Chinese e-commerce giant. After Alibaba went public, Mayer and the company came up with a plan to sell Yahoo's remaining stake, and hoped to avoid having to pay taxes on the sale.

jack ma
Sean Gallup/Getty Images
Advertisement

Even so, Mayer is credited for drastically improving some of Yahoo's product designs and traffic to its core apps. Some people say she changed the internal culture at Yahoo and brought back some excitement.

Yahoo
twitter.com/jypark04070

But revenue in Yahoo's core business has stubbornly refused to pick up, and for the last few months, Mayer has been under fire.

Marissa Mayer
Marissa Mayer, CEO of Yahoo, attends the Cannes Lions 2014, 61st International Advertising Festival in Cannes, southern France, Tuesday, June 17, 2014. AP Photo/Lionel Cironneau
Advertisement

Investors were spooked in September 2015 when the IRS declined to rule on Yahoo's request for a "pre-ruling" that the Alibaba sale would be tax-free. That doesn't necessarily mean that Yahoo would have to pay taxes, but it added uncertainty, sending Yahoo's stock down 4%.

IRS John Koskinen
In this June 2, 2015, file photo, Internal Revenue Service (IRS) Commissioner John Koskinen testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington. About 1.8 million households that got financial help for health insurance under President Barack Obama’s law have issues with their tax returns that could jeopardize their subsidies next year. AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin

Top lieutenants have departed, like CMO Kathy Savitt and CDO Jackie Reses (shown here). Some have questioned her acquisition strategy, too, where she spent roughly $3 billion to buy startups, none of which translated to meaningful growth.

Yahoo Jacqueline Reses
Yahoo's M&A and HR chief, Jacqueline Reses Fortune Brainstorm TECH
Advertisement

A hedge fund manager, Eric Jackson, sent a 99-page slide explaining why Yahoo needs new management. He suggested dramatically cutting the company's size and jettisoning businesses like search. In January, activist investor Starboard sent a letter demanding "significant changes" over Yahoo's management, board, and strategy.

Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer
Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer delivers her keynote address at the annual Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas, Nevada January 7, 2014. REUTERS/Robert Galbraith

Read Jackson's slide deck here.

Recent reports say that some Yahoo employees are losing their trust in Mayer's ability to turn the company around. Sources told Business Insider that it plans to lay off more than 10% of its workforce in the coming weeks.

Yahoo
A Yahoo billboard is seen in New York's Times Square October 19, 2010. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid
Advertisement

Now, Yahoo is rumored to be considering a sale of its core business, which includes its online content and advertising units, as a way to unlock the value of the Alibaba stake. Pressure is mounting for Mayer, and the clock is ticking for her to save Yahoo.

Marissa Mayer CEO Yahoo
Marissa Mayer, President and CEO of Yahoo, participates in a panel discussion at the 2015 Fortune Global Forum in San Francisco, California November 3, 2015. REUTERS/Elijah Nouvelage
Advertisement
Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.