What it's like to eat a $295-per-person, 3-hour dinner at Eleven Madison Park, the best restaurant in America

Business Insider recently released its list of the best restaurants in America, and for the second year in a row, Eleven Madison Park claimed the No. 1 spot.

Advertisement

We can see why. With Michelin-starred chef Daniel Humm at the helm, the French-influenced bistro serves exceptional Greenmarket cuisine that surprises and delights.

Food blogger Julian Fang captured the experience of dining at Eleven Madison Park in spring 2011 for his website Jewelz. He opted for the 11-course tasting menu, which today runs three and a half hours and costs $295 per person.

Eleven Madison Park
New York's Eleven Madison Park is the No. 1 restaurant in America.
Francesco Tonelli

While the menu has changed, the decadence remains. We've shared a selection of Fang's photos with permission.

Advertisement

Daniel Humm's award-winning restaurant is located in Manhattan's Flatiron neighborhood, on Madison Avenue between 24th and 25th Streets.

eleven madison park restaurant exterior
Melia Robinson/Business Insider

The Art Deco-styled dining room features floor-to-ceiling windows and whimsical floral arrangements that reach to the high ceilings.

eleven madison park 1
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

But let's get to the food. Eleven Madison Park only offers a tasting menu, preceded by light amuse-bouches. First up were these bite-sized cheese gougéres, served warm and sprinkled with salt.

eleven madison park 2
Flickr/djjewelz

As diners snacked on the pastry puffs, they perused the exhaustive beverage menu. A 2006 Arnot-Roberts syrah wine was selected.

eleven madison park 10
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

After the wine arrived, a narrow tray of hor d'oeuvres followed. Let's take a closer look at each.

eleven madison park 4
Flickr/djjewelz

If you like your vegetables best prepared as ice cream toppings, the playful carrot marshmallow is for you.

eleven madison park 9
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

The tuna tartare blended textures and tastes.

eleven madison park 8
Flickr/djjewelz

Over the years, Eleven Madison Park has made its famous foie gras seared, cured, and made into pudding. This preparation came topped with an asparagus gelée.

eleven madison park 7
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

The crispy sweetbread-stuffed cornet added a bit of crunch.

eleven madison park 5
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

Wine glass empty? Swap it out for a mint julep with a bouquet of mint leaves so large, you could wear it as a hat at the Kentucky Derby.

eleven madison park 11
Flickr/djjewelz

Bread service signaled the beginning of the official meal.

eleven madison park 32
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

The warm, flaky rolls were made richer by goat- and cow-milk butters.

eleven madison park 22
Flickr/djjewelz

The first course, Sterling Royal Caviar, came nestled with spheres of smoked sturgeon and salmon cream.

eleven madison park 12
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

This course features three different ingredients at three different temperatures: Santa Barbara sea urchin, custard with green apple, and shellfish ragout. Together they make a decadent, sour, briny, and somehow great combination.

eleven madison park 14
Flickr/djjewelz

Here's what the dish looks like once you've cracked the surface.

eleven madison park 15
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

The garden pea and mint lollipop arrives in a glass vase filled with grass.

eleven madison park 16
Flickr/djjewelz

Eleven Madison Park prides itself on serving locally grown foods. The Spring Out of Winter course pairs freshly harvested asparagus with Jamón Ibérico.

eleven madison park 18
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

Another gorgeous foie gras preparation, this melt-on-your-tongue foie gras torchon accompanies tête de cochon, pickled spring vegetables, and horseradish.

eleven madison park 20
Flickr/djjewelz

Tender, buttery Atlantic Halibut was seared with smoked spring garlic and crayfish.

eleven madison park 24
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

The Earth and Ocean course combined land and sea influences. Nearly unrecognizable as chicken, a slow-cooked poussin was served with Hawaiian blue prawns and seaweed.

eleven madison park 28
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

Four different preparations of Colorado lamb accompanied the large, pink, herb-roasted cut in the center of the plate. The lamb ravioli, lamb sausage, lamb short rib, and sweetbreads proved there's no wrong way to eat it.

eleven madison park 29
Flickr/djjewelz

A dining room manager delivered the star of the meal, the Muscovy duck stuffed with lavender and glazed with honey, to the table.

eleven madison park lavendar honey duck
Flickr/T.Tseng

Photo by Flickr user T.Tseng.

Advertisement

He carved the bird and plated it right there, so other diners could watch on and drool. The choicest morsels were served alongside asparagus, ramps, and strawberries.

eleven madison park 31
Flickr/djjewelz

Next, a fromage cart pulled up tableside. The server doled out a selection of artisanal cheese based on the diner's preferences.

eleven madison park 33
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

These adorable raisin walnut bread sticks paired well with the cheese assortment.

eleven madison park 21
Flickr/djjewelz

Dinner now transitioned into its final stage: dessert. The "Soda Pop" — which actually made a popping sound with each bite, thanks to a helping of Pop Rocks — was constructed out of tangerine foam frozen with liquid nitrogen.

eleven madison park 34
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

An interesting take on the milk and cookies, the Milk and Chocolate course combined dehydrated chocolate mousse, caramelized white chocolate sorbet, browned milk solids, and other rich cocoa textures.

eleven madison park 35
Flickr/djjewelz

The final course, a generous plate of macarons, offered an even greater variety of flavors. The macarons came in pink peppercorn with caramel, chocolate banana, peanut butter, coconut with chocolate ganache, Meyer lemon, toasted sesame with green tea, and grapefruit with fennel.

eleven madison park 37
Flickr/djjewelz
Advertisement

Don't forget the parting favor: a small box of jellies.

eleven madison park jellies
Flickr/djjewelz
Arts & Culture
Advertisement
Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.